Naturalism, Honesty & Heightened Reality

Had an interesting chat with an actor in class the other week, who was questioning whether my taste and his taste were compatible for further training. At issue was the topic of “naturalism,” for which my from-the-hip definition would be, “that style of acting where the unadorned presence of the actor, delivering the lines of the script in a ‘real’ way, is all that is required to tell the story.”

I perhaps too often decry naturalism, not because it isn’t useful or in demand, but because it’s boring. I find the acting in most network television to be boring, and the style these days is marked by excessive naturalism. That being said, I’ve written plenty about how actors need to know what project they’re reading for, and if the show is marked by a naturalistic style, they’d better serve it up and give themselves a real shot for a paycheck.

Prior to our conversation, I’d seen this actor do a scene from Guirgis’ “Motherfucker with the Hat” and Mamet’s recent play, “Race.” I don’t believe either of those writers deals in naturalism as a style, and in both, I felt this actor’s naturalistic tendency was inhibiting the full expression of the writing.  So I redirected both scenes as part of the critique, complete with line-readings, because I’m that guy – the jerk who’ll give line-readings from here to Timbuktu if that’s what it takes. The actor was not pleased – hence our conversation.

He felt “naturalism” was more closely related to “honesty.” To be natural was to be honest, to be real, and that was the start point of all good acting. So he hears “natural” and thinks “honest,” and I say “natural” and mean “boring.” So…. You can see why he’s wondering whether to continue!

I enjoy conversations like this, actually, because I figure there are others who think just as this guy does, but he happened to be forthright enough to come and speak to me about it. So to be clear:  We both want the work to be honest, to represent real people in real situations, so the audience believes what is happening in the story. To me that’s a good expression of the ultimate simplicity of acting’s purpose: “To make the audience believe the story.” That is a very agreeable startpoint for me in judging acting – do I believe what’s going on here? And yeah, simple naturalistic acting, if that’s what the writing and the story require, is often good enough to make me believe. Job done.

I just happen also to think we go to the movies and to the theatre for something a touch beyond that which we see every day at Starbucks. And it’s not just the stories that will take us there, but some vivid acting – this is particularly true in theatre, which as a form is auditory, versus tv/film, which is a visual medium. So in theatre I believe we really have to hear the play, and each has its own music, its own rhythm. Playwrights are often much freer to express themselves at length, and in order to bring the music to life, something beyond simple reality is necessary. And, further, I believe that actors who can use good writing to expand their expression will be better suited and more valuable even to those naturalistic styles and shows, because every so often you need a little ka-pow, and a little rhythm, and some more expressive style….

So in class when I decry ‘naturalism,’ it’s only that for most advanced level actors, to sit there and be ‘real’ is not so much a chore, and I don’t want to be the guy who collects tuition to validate what they can already do. I think a class should also serve to expand those boundaries, and encourage actors to look at writing that allows, even demands, that expansion. For actors starting out, getting them to be natural on stage, and able to bring to life a simple conversation without artifice – this is very important. So this essay is somewhat directed toward the more advanced actor in class. For many of these actors, the job of getting work on a naturalistic network show is more a matter of administrative discipline and getting out there than it is one of acting ability. Terrific careers can happen on the usage of 30% of your talent, but I think actors need to be in the gym, working out 100% of the talent in order for even that 30% to shine the way they want.

 

If you enjoyed this post, please consider sharing it and leaving a comment.
Share Button
This entry was posted in Acting. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Naturalism, Honesty & Heightened Reality

  1. Ashley says:

    Very interesting. Thanks for the clarity

  2. Jennifer Gelfer says:

    Amazing. I literally had this same conversation with a student in my class. You put it so well. I plan to send it to everyone in my class

  3. Alex says:

    Wow, this is so true. As a playwright I write dialogue where I need actors to be aware of exactly this.
    This is a great article, and if you write comedic plays you need actors to get the comedy which is often not naturalistic.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Search

F— Improv Training

Allow me to rage, give voice to thoughts hushed and guarded, unexpressed, trapped, traversing the crania of teachers of ...
Readmore...

Cynema (Or Cinema with a WHY?)

[I posted this entry in 2010, but the topic keeps smacking me in the face, so I thought it was worth revisiting with an ...
Readmore...

Peer to Peer

I've emphasized in plenty of entries here how important I think it is that actors follow up on all professional interact ...
Readmore...

A Prism Doesn’t Think

An actor is a prism. The writing is the light. Each writer, being utterly unique, will create a different variation o ...
Readmore...

What is Required Of Me By This Story?

Here's a question I think actors should ask themselves more often: What is required of me by this story? Asking th ...
Readmore...

Showcases, Workshops & Integrity

Lights up on.... An agent showcase. Over the next hour or so, fifteen scenes will be performed, about 3 minutes each. Al ...
Readmore...

Patton Oswalt Nails It

A student of mine sent this to me - comedian Patton Oswalt's keynote at last year's Just For Laughs Comedy Festival. It ...
Readmore...

The Wall Of No

My wife recently had coffee with a very successful entrepreneur, and he told her he wakes up every morning "wanting to h ...
Readmore...

Script, Uh, Discipline – Right? Huh? SALLY?

My rapidly advancing age has perhaps made me downright persnickety, but for some reason my ear has become more sensitive ...
Readmore...

Lifecycle

From the Department of Context, a sketch of the lifecycle of a project. In boldface, the items over which actors have co ...
Readmore...

Naturalism, Honesty & Heightened Reality

Had an interesting chat with an actor in class the other week, who was questioning whether my taste and his taste were c ...
Readmore...

Somebody Said That Somebody Said….

....that you're a jerk. ....that you did something horrible. ....that your audition sucked. ....that your relat ...
Readmore...

A Universal Career Jumpstart

Ask a majority of actors what's going on with their career, and you'll likely get a fuzzy look, the eyes will wander thi ...
Readmore...

Sexuality Neurosis

One of the biggest acting class cliches are actors who say they are "working on their sexuality." The fact that 90% of t ...
Readmore...

How’d the Audition Go?

Who cares? You book it, or not, and you move on (with impeccable followup, of course). When good actors go too long w ...
Readmore...

Slouching Towards Bitterness

Oh, the perils of turning 30 in the pursuit of acting! It's been on my mind for a while, as I have taught long enough ...
Readmore...

A Good Attitude….

.... consists mainly of the the ability to behave professionally and take action despite your bad attitude.

The Branding Myth

Count me opposed to the needless and introspective thought process that has been introduced to what we at the Beverly Hi ...
Readmore...

Gay Actors, Straight Roles

Much of the difficulty in addressing the issue of whether a ‘gay actor can play straight’ is due to its being confla ...
Readmore...

MyGigInfo.com Release Update

The performance-tracking website I've been developing for a couple years has gone through a significant revision this su ...
Readmore...

Why Comedy Scenes Go Awry

Two reasons, generally: 1) Lack of energy. Comedy is often a dramatization of two or more colliding points of view. T ...
Readmore...

Gunplay

I'm not a fan of gunplay on stage. And this goes beyond the safety considerations, because for the purposes of this disc ...
Readmore...

The “Do Less” Cunundrum

Ask an actor for the most frequent adjustment they hear when going in for your average film or television audition (but ...
Readmore...

Name That Tone

When Milton and I reworked the Acting Class book in 2008, we flirted with the idea of moving "Who's The Author?" to the ...
Readmore...

On Technology and Training: A Steinway Metaphor

There’s a fabulous documentary on the topic of making Steinway pianos - Note by Note: The Making of Steinway L1037.  ...
Readmore...

On Being Personal

A little over a year ago, I was asked to write an essay about "Being Personal," for a book that was to be a collection o ...
Readmore...

Feelings Don’t Matter

They just don't. There is the job you do, and then there are your feelings about your job - and only the former is of an ...
Readmore...

A Slow Turning Wheel

Part of the Big Frustration with pursuing an acting career I think comes from the seeming zero relationship between comp ...
Readmore...

Introducing MyGigInfo.com

About four years ago, I had an idea. I made some sketches of it at the time, had some basic conversations with web devel ...
Readmore...

Leonard Cohen, “How to Speak Poetry”

From Death of a Lady's Man: Take the word "butterfly." To use this word it is not necessary to make the voice weigh l ...
Readmore...